1.800.561.4007 info@ironspear.ca

The Hidden Risk in Every Critical Service: Why Bill C-8 Puts Supply Chain Security in the Spotlight

For decades, cybersecurity focused on building higher walls around the enterprise. Organizations invested heavily in data centres, firewalls, endpoint protection, and perimeter security. The goal was simple: protect what was inside. That model no longer reflects reality. 

Today, organizations rely on a complex web of cloud providers, software vendors, managed service providers, telecommunications partners, and countless other third parties to deliver services. As digital transformation has accelerated, so too has the realization that cybersecurity is no longer confined to an organization’s own environment.

This shift is one reason Canada’s proposed Bill C-8, the Critical Cyber Systems Protection Act, places significant emphasis on supply chain and third-party risk management.

According to Drew Carmichael, Vice President at Iron Spear Information Security, the growing attention is not simply a regulatory trend. It is a recognition of how modern services are delivered. “No organization can deliver most of its services by itself. Almost every service relies on third parties in some way, especially with the advent of cloud. Every organization now depends on third parties to deliver services.”

The Disappearing Perimeter

Historically, organizations operated within a well-defined security perimeter. Data resided in corporate data centres protected by physical security, firewalls, and tightly controlled access. That perimeter is rapidly disappearing.

Cloud services, outsourced platforms, and interconnected digital ecosystems have fundamentally changed how information moves and where it resides. Data is frequently processed, stored, and transmitted through environments outside the direct control of the organization that owns it. As a result, the security of critical services increasingly depends on the security practices of external providers.

“We cannot deliver securely unless they deliver securely,” Carmichael explains.

The challenge is straightforward but significant: organizations must understand whether their suppliers possess the controls, governance, and recovery capabilities necessary to protect sensitive information and support business operations.

Why Organizations Accumulate Security Debt

Most organizations do not intentionally create security debt. It accumulates gradually as business priorities compete for time, budget, and resources.

Security teams are often balancing operational demands, compliance requirements, cloud initiatives, digital transformation projects, and day-to-day support activities. When resources are stretched, remediation activities can be delayed in favour of more immediate business needs.

The scale of the challenge continues to grow. Industry research shows that more than 21,500 new vulnerabilities were disclosed in 2025, with 38% rated High or Critical severity. Security teams are struggling to keep pace with the volume of issues requiring assessment and remediation.

At the same time, security debt is becoming increasingly common. Recent research found that 50% of organizations now carry critical security debt, defined as security flaws that remain unresolved for more than a year.

Over time, deferred decisions accumulate, creating a growing backlog of known risks that require ongoing management.

You Can Outsource the Function, But Not the Risk

One of the most important principles behind supplier risk management is accountability. Many organizations believe that transferring a service to a vendor also transfers the associated risk. Regulators increasingly disagree.

Bill C-8 reinforces a long-standing governance principle: organizations remain accountable for the services they provide, regardless of who performs the work. “You can outsource the function, but you cannot outsource the risk.”

 Even if a third-party provider experiences the breach or outage, customers, regulators, and stakeholders will still expect the contracting organization to explain how risks were assessed, monitored, and managed. This reality places greater emphasis on supplier due diligence, contractual obligations, and ongoing oversight programs.

Thinking Like an Auditor

Managing third-party risk requires a different mindset than managing internal cybersecurity. Inside the organization, leaders can rely on employee policies, internal controls, and audit functions. With external providers, those mechanisms are significantly more limited. 

According to Carmichael, organizations must instead focus on clearly defining security objectives and communicating those expectations to suppliers.

Questions such as:

  • How should data be protected?
  • What controls are required?
  • What monitoring and audit mechanisms exist?
  • What notification timelines apply following an incident?
  • What recovery capabilities must be maintained?

 These expectations must be documented and agreed upon in advance. “We have to think in terms of how we clearly articulate to third parties what we expect of them, in writing and in advance.”

The most mature organizations also recognize that supplier management is fundamentally risk-based. A vendor’s suitability depends on the organization’s regulatory obligations, risk tolerance, and business objectives. A supplier that is appropriate for one company may not meet another’s requirements.

The Business Continuity Challenge

Perhaps the most overlooked aspect of supplier risk management is business continuity. Traditional disaster recovery planning focused on internal assets and capabilities. Organizations planned for fires, floods, power outages, and facility disruptions. Recovery strategies centred on backup infrastructure and alternate operating locations.

Modern recovery planning is far more complicated. Cloud providers, software-as-a-service platforms, managed service providers, and telecommunications partners often control critical components of the recovery process. 

An organization may have an aggressive recovery objective, but success ultimately depends on suppliers achieving complementary recovery outcomes. “If the provider of your cloud storage cannot recover, it does not matter how good your own data centre recovery capabilities are.”

For organizations supporting critical services, this dependency becomes even more significant. The resilience of essential societal functions increasingly depends on the resilience of interconnected suppliers.

The Surprising Gaps Organizations Discover

When organizations begin evaluating supply chain risk, the first challenge is often visibility. Many believe they have a solid understanding of their supplier ecosystem until they attempt to document it. 

Common discoveries include:

  • Incomplete supplier inventories
  • Unknown supplier access to sensitive information
  • Undocumented remote access privileges
  • Critical business processes supported by overlooked vendors
  • Limited understanding of recovery dependencies
  • Contractual gaps that reduce accountability

In many cases, the issue is not that suppliers are performing poorly. The issue is that expectations were never clearly defined. “Sometimes the surprise is that the organization never clearly defined what it expected from them in the first place.”

Evidence Matters

Bill C-8 signals a broader shift from policy-based compliance toward evidence-based assurance. Organizations will increasingly need to demonstrate not only that supplier risk management processes exist, but that they are actively followed.

Regulators are likely to expect evidence such as:

  • Supplier inventories and criticality assessments
  • Third-party due diligence records
  • Security questionnaires and assessment results
  • Contractual security obligations
  • Incident reporting procedures
  • Governance documentation
  • Supplier monitoring activities
  • Recovery testing results

Most importantly, organizations must demonstrate a risk-based approach that allocates oversight proportional to supplier criticality. The company collecting recyclables from an office should not receive the same level of scrutiny as the provider hosting critical customer data.

Where Organizations Should Start

For many organizations, Carmichael believes the first step is surprisingly simple.

Create a list. “If you asked today, ‘What are your key suppliers?’ many could not tell you.”

Developing a comprehensive inventory of suppliers, the services they provide, the business processes they support, and the internal owners responsible for those relationships creates the foundation of any effective supplier risk program.

 

From there, organizations can assess criticality through practical questions:

  • Does the supplier support a critical business process?
  • Do they have access to sensitive information?
  • Do they have remote access into our environment?
  • Could the business operate without them for several days or weeks?
  • Are their recovery capabilities aligned with ours?

The answers quickly reveal which relationships require the greatest attention.

The Road Ahead

As regulatory expectations continue to evolve, third-party risk management is becoming a core element of cybersecurity governance rather than a specialized discipline.

The organizations best positioned to meet these expectations will be those that understand their supply chains, document their dependencies, establish clear security expectations, and continuously validate supplier performance. For many, that journey is only beginning.

About Iron Spear Information Security

Iron Spear Information Security is a Canadian cybersecurity consulting firm specializing in cyber governance, risk management, security assessments, incident response, threat modelling, and cybersecurity program development. Working with organizations across critical infrastructure, financial services, government, utilities, and education, Iron Spear helps clients develop practical, risk-based security programs that align with business objectives while meeting evolving regulatory expectations.

In an era where cyber resilience depends as much on suppliers as internal systems, organizations need more than compliance. They need confidence that every link in the chain is strong. Iron Spear helps provide that confidence.

https://ironspear.ca